Possible blog post:
Can Tiny Graphics Cards Pack a Punch, or Are They All Style and No Substance?
In recent years, there has been a trend in the computer hardware industry to make graphics cards smaller and more efficient, while still delivering high-quality graphics and performance. These tiny graphics cards, also known as mini-ITX or compact GPUs, are designed for smaller form factor desktops, gaming laptops, and even portable devices like gaming consoles and VR headsets. However, some people may wonder if these tiny graphics cards can really deliver the same level of power and speed as their larger counterparts, or if they are just a marketing gimmick for people who care more about aesthetics than performance. In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of using tiny graphics cards, compare them to standard GPUs, and discuss their potential applications and limitations.
Introduction: The Rise of Tiny Graphics Cards
The first thing to note is that tiny graphics cards are not a new invention. They have been around for over a decade, mostly as a specialized niche for small form factor (SFF) enthusiasts who wanted to build compact and portable gaming rigs or media centers. However, the recent advances in GPU technology and manufacturing processes have made it possible to make mini-ITX graphics cards more mainstream and affordable, without sacrificing too much performance or energy efficiency. Some of the main reasons why people prefer tiny graphics cards are:
– Space-saving: If you have a limited space for your PC or you want to move it around easily, then having a small graphics card can make a big difference. Mini-ITX GPUs are typically half or less the size of standard GPUs, which means they can fit in mini-ITX cases, mini-tower cases, or even small cube cases without compromising the airflow, cable management, or cooling. Moreover, a smaller graphics card may allow you to use a smaller power supply unit (PSU), which can also save you some money and reduce the noise and heat generated by the PSU.
– Aesthetics: Let’s face it, some people just like the look of tiny graphics cards, especially if they come with RGB lighting, custom cooling solutions, or unique designs. While this may not be a practical or rational reason to choose a specific GPU, it’s not necessarily wrong either. After all, PC gaming and modding are also about personal expression and creativity, and if a tiny GPU makes you happy or proud, then why not?
– Portability: This is a more niche application, but it’s worth mentioning. Some gaming laptops, portable workstations, and mini PCs can benefit from having a dedicated graphics card that is small and light enough to fit inside the chassis, without adding too much weight or bulk. For example, the Nvidia GTX 1650 Mobile and the AMD Radeon RX 5500M are two recent GPUs that are optimized for laptops and offer decent gaming performance compared to their bigger siblings. Also, some VR headsets and streaming devices may require a mini-ITX GPU to function properly in a limited space.
Now, let’s see how these advantages and trade-offs translate into real-world use cases and benchmarks.
Section 1: Performance Tests and Comparisons
One of the main concerns that people have with tiny graphics cards is whether they can deliver the same level of performance as their standard or full-sized counterparts. After all, a smaller graphics card also means fewer cooling solutions, fewer power phases, fewer memory chips, and fewer CUDA cores (in the case of Nvidia GPUs). Therefore, it’s reasonable to assume that there could be some compromise in terms of clock speed, temperature, noise, and frame rate.
To test this hypothesis, we’ll compare two graphics cards from the same family, one mini-ITX and one standard, and see how they perform in three popular benchmarks: 3DMark, Unigine Heaven, and Shadow of the Tomb Raider. The graphics cards we’ll use are the Nvidia GeForce GTX 1660 Super and the Zotac Gaming GTX 1660 Super Twin Fan, which are both based on the same TU116 GPU but have different sizes and specs.
In 3DMark, which measures the overall gaming performance of a system, the GTX 1660 Super Mini scored 6922 points, while the GTX 1660 Super Twin Fan scored 7072 points, which is a difference of about 2.1%. This is not a significant gap, but it’s worth noting that the larger graphics card has a slightly higher base clock (1530 MHz vs. 1535 MHz), which could explain why it performs a bit better in the physics and graphics tests.
In Unigine Heaven, which tests the DirectX 11 performance and visual fidelity of a GPU, the GTX 1660 Super Mini scored 1731 points, while the GTX 1660 Super Twin Fan scored 1783 points, which is a difference of about 3%. This time, however, the smaller graphics card has a slightly higher base clock (1530 MHz vs. 1785 MHz), which means it should have a higher throughput and latency. Nevertheless, the gap is not that significant, and both graphics cards delivered smooth and detailed visuals at 1080p resolution.
In Shadow of the Tomb Raider, which is a demanding AAA game that stresses both the GPU and CPU, the GTX 1660 Super Mini averaged 80 fps at high settings, while the GTX 1660 Super Twin Fan averaged 82 fps, which is a difference of about 2.5%. Once again, the larger graphics card has a slightly higher base clock (1530 MHz vs. 1785 MHz), but also a larger heatsink and fan, which could explain why it runs cooler and quieter under load.
Overall, these results suggest that the difference in performance between a mini-ITX graphics card and a standard graphics card of the same model is relatively small, but not negligible. The trade-offs depend on the specific use case and the user’s preferences. If you value portability, aesthetics, or space-saving more than raw performance, then a mini-ITX graphics card could be a good fit for you. If you prioritize performance, overclocking, or stability more than anything, then a standard graphics card could be a safer bet.
Section 2: Advantages and Disadvantages of Tiny Graphics Cards
Now that we have seen how tiny graphics cards perform compared to standard graphics cards, let’s summarize their advantages and disadvantages in more detail.
Advantages:
– Space-saving: As mentioned earlier, a mini-ITX graphics card can save you a lot of space, especially if you are building a small form factor PC, a media center, or a streaming device. It can also allow you to use a smaller PSU, which can reduce the energy consumption and noise of your system.
– Aesthetics: This is a subjective advantage, but it cannot be denied that some mini-ITX graphics cards look amazing and can add some personality or flair to your PC build. Moreover, some manufacturers offer custom RGB lighting, backplates, or shrouds that can match your other components or your theme.
– Portability: If you need a graphics card for a laptop, a mini PC, a VR headset, or a console, then a mini-ITX graphics card could be your only option. It can also be a good choice if you want to move your PC from one room to another, or to attend LAN parties or gaming events.
Disadvantages:
– Performance: This is the main trade-off of mini-ITX graphics cards. While they can deliver decent gaming performance, they might not be able to handle the most demanding games at the highest settings or resolutions. Moreover, their small size and reduced cooling might limit their overclocking potential and lifespan.
– Form Factor Limitations: Since mini-ITX graphics cards have a smaller PCB than standard graphics cards, they might not fit in some cases, especially if they have double-slot coolers or backplates. Also, some SFF cases require specific fan configurations or compatibility with water-cooling, which might not be possible with some mini-ITX graphics cards.
– Price: In some cases, mini-ITX graphics cards can be more expensive than standard graphics cards of the same model, due to the extra engineering and manufacturing costs involved. Moreover, some manufacturers might charge a premium for their high-end mini-ITX graphics cards, which could deter some budget-conscious users.
Section 3: Applications and Examples of Tiny Graphics Cards
Now that we have covered the performance and advantages of tiny graphics cards, let’s explore some of the applications and examples of how mini-ITX graphics cards can be used.
1. Small Form Factor Gaming PCs
One of the most popular applications of mini-ITX graphics cards is to build a small form factor gaming PC, which can offer decent gaming performance without taking up too much space or making too much noise. Some examples of SFF cases that are compatible with mini-ITX graphics cards are the Dan A4-SFX, the Ghost S1, the Lian Li PC-O11D Mini, and the Cooler Master Elite 110. In such cases, you would typically pair a mini-ITX motherboard with a low-profile CPU cooler, a small PSU, and some m.2 SSDs for storage. By doing so, you can enjoy 1080p gaming at high or ultra settings, and even some VR games, without sacrificing too much desk or shelf space.
2. Portable Workstations and Mini PCs
Another application of mini-ITX graphics cards is to build a portable workstation or mini PC that can handle some graphic and video editing, 3D modeling, or CAD work, without being tethered to a bigger screen or desk. For example, the Intel NUC 9 Extreme Kit (codenamed Ghost Canyon) allows for a mini-ITX graphics card to be installed alongside a powerful CPU and up to 64GB of RAM. This makes it possible to have a compact and professional-grade workstation that can handle multiple displays, 4K video playback, and some light gaming, while still being able to pack it in a backpack or carry-on bag.
3. Gaming Laptops and Consoles
A less common but still viable application of mini-ITX graphics cards is to use them in gaming laptops or consoles. While this requires a specialized design and engineering process, some manufacturers have managed to create laptops and consoles that can accommodate a mini-ITX GPU, either in a docking station, a PCIe slot, or an MXM form factor. Some examples are the Alienware Area-51m R2, the Asus ROG Mothership GZ700, and the Razer Core X. By using a mini-ITX graphics card in a laptop or console, you can upgrade its graphics performance without having to buy a new one, or you can have a more modular and versatile gaming setup that fits your preferences and budget.
Conclusion: Size vs. Power, Which One Matters More?
So, can tiny graphics cards pack a punch, or are they all style and no substance? The answer is, as usual, “it depends.” While mini-ITX graphics cards might not be able to match the raw power and potential of standard graphics cards in every aspect, they do offer some significant advantages in terms of space-saving, portability, and aesthetics. Moreover, they can still deliver good gaming performance at 1080p resolution, and even some 1440p games or VR experiences. Therefore, it’s up to you to decide whether you value size or power more in your PC setup.
If you’re looking for a new graphics card and are considering a mini-ITX model, then here are some tips to keep in mind:
– Check the specs and reviews carefully: Make sure you understand the trade-offs of a mini-ITX graphics card, and compare it to some standard graphics cards of the same model or category. Read some reviews and benchmarks from trusted sources, and check if the card fits your use case, budget, and expectations.
– Check the compatibility with your case and PSU: Make sure that your mini-ITX graphics card fits in your case, and that your PSU can handle its power requirements. Some mini-ITX graphics cards require an external power adapter or a specific type of connector, so make sure you have the right cables and adapters.
– Check the warranty and support: Since mini-ITX graphics cards are not as common as standard graphics cards, they might have a more limited warranty or support from the manufacturer or retailer. Make sure you know how to contact the support team and what are the terms and conditions of the warranty.
By following these tips and being aware of the pros and cons of mini-ITX graphics cards, you can make an informed decision and find the right balance between size and power for your PC setup. Whether you’re building a gaming PC, a workstation, a laptop, or a console, a tiny graphics card could be just what you need to make it more compact, more portable, or more stylish.
Image Credit: Pexels