Possible blog post:
How CPUs Crunch Numbers Faster than a Flash: Exploring the Secrets of Modern Processing Power
What makes a CPU (central processing unit) the brain of a computer? How can it execute billions of instructions per second, carry out complex algorithms, and run multiple programs at once, all while consuming relatively little energy and generating minimal heat? How does it avoid errors, handle exceptions, and interact with other components in a computer system? These are some of the fascinating questions that fascinate not only computer scientists and hardware enthusiasts, but also anyone who uses a computer or a smartphone today.
In this blog post, we will delve into the wonders of CPU performance, from the basics of how transistors and logic gates work, to the latest advances in multicore processing, vectorization, and artificial intelligence. We will aim to explain these concepts in plain English, with analogies and examples that can help anyone understand the essence of how CPUs work. We will also provide some actionable tips on how to optimize CPU usage and troubleshoot common performance issues. By the end of this post, you will have a better appreciation of the power and versatility of CPUs, and how they can help you accomplish amazing things, whether you are writing code, playing games, editing videos, or browsing the web.
I. The Fundamentals of CPU Architecture
Before we can explore the secrets of CPU performance, we need to lay down some basic concepts of digital electronics. We assume that you are already familiar with the binary number system, and can convert decimal numbers to binary and vice versa. If not, there are many online resources that can help you learn this essential skill.
A. Transistors: The Building Blocks of Chips
A transistor is a semiconductor device that can act as a switch or an amplifier, depending on its configuration and the applied voltage. It has three terminals, called the emitter, the base, and the collector. When a current flows from the emitter to the collector, it can be controlled by a smaller current applied to the base. By varying the voltage on the base, one can make the transistor either conduct (allow current to flow) or cut off (block current). This basic principle allows transistors to perform logical operations, such as AND, OR, NOT, NAND, NOR, XOR, and XNOR, which are the building blocks of digital circuits.
For example, if we want to implement a simple OR gate with two inputs, A and B, we can use two transistors in parallel, with their collectors tied together, and their bases biased by the input voltages. If either A or B is high (i.e., at a logic level of 1), the corresponding transistor will conduct and current will flow to the output. If both A and B are low (i.e., at a logic level of 0), both transistors will be cut off and no current will flow. If we want to implement an AND gate, we can use two transistors in series, with their collectors connected to the output, and their bases biased by the input voltages. Only if both A and B are high will both transistors conduct and current will flow to the output. If either A or B is low, the corresponding transistor will be cut off and no current will flow.
By combining multiple transistors in different ways, we can build more complex logic circuits, such as adders, shifters, multiplexers, demultiplexers, and registers. We can also integrate them into a single piece of silicon, called a chip or a microprocessor. A chip can contain millions or billions of transistors, arranged in intricate patterns that allow it to perform a wide range of tasks. However, the number of transistors per unit area is not the only factor that determines the performance and efficiency of a chip. Other factors include the speed of the transistors, the power supply voltage, the thermal design, the cache hierarchy, the instruction set architecture, and the software optimization.
B. Clocking: The Heartbeat of a CPU
A CPU needs a way to coordinate the activities of its transistors and circuits, and to synchronize them with external devices and events. The most common method used in modern CPUs is called clocking, which involves an external crystal oscillator that generates a periodic signal, called a clock waveform, that serves as the heartbeat of the system.
The frequency of the clock waveform determines the rate at which the CPU can cycle through its instructions, and the latency of its operations, which is the time it takes for a result to become available after an input is provided. The clock frequency is measured in hertz (Hz), which represents the number of cycles per second. A typical desktop CPU today can run at frequencies ranging from 1 GHz (one billion cycles per second) to 5 GHz or more, depending on the architecture, the process technology, and the thermal constraints.
The clock waveform is usually divided into discrete phases, called clock cycles, or ticks, during each of which a portion of the CPU’s internal operations is carried out. At the end of each cycle, the outputs of the logic gates and registers are latched, and the next input signals are read. This cycle repeats indefinitely, as long as the CPU is powered on and receiving a clock signal. The clock waveform also defines the critical path of the CPU, which is the longest path that determines the maximum achievable frequency and the minimum propagation delay.
Of course, clocking has its limits and trade-offs. Increasing the clock frequency beyond a certain point can lead to diminishing returns, as well as increased power consumption and heat dissipation. It can also introduce more noise and jitter, which can affect the accuracy and stability of the system. Therefore, modern CPUs employ sophisticated techniques to optimize the clocking, such as dynamic frequency scaling, which adjusts the clock frequency based on the workload and the power budget, and clock gating, which selectively disables some parts of the CPU when they are not needed, to save power.
C. Instruction Execution: The Logic of Computation
Now that we have a basic idea of how transistors and clocks work, let’s see how CPUs use them to execute instructions. An instruction is a binary code that represents a specific operation or a sequence of operations, such as adding two numbers, fetching data from memory, or jumping to a different section of the code. An instruction can be encoded using a fixed-length or variable-length format, depending on the instruction set architecture (ISA) of the CPU. An ISA is a specification that defines the syntax, semantics, and behavior of the instructions that a CPU can understand and execute.
For example, the x86 ISA, which is used by most desktop and laptop CPUs today, has hundreds of different instructions, such as mov (move data), add (addition), sub (subtraction), mul (multiplication), div (division), cmp (comparison), jmp (jump), call (call subroutine), and ret (return from subroutine), among others. Each instruction has a specific opcode (operation code) that identifies its type and parameters, and can be decoded by the CPU’s control unit, which is a circuit that retrieves the instructions from memory and manages their execution.
When an instruction is fetched from memory, it is loaded into a special register called the instruction pointer (IP), or program counter (PC), which stores the memory address of the next instruction to be executed. The PC is incremented by the size of the instruction, which allows the CPU to fetch the next instruction from the correct address. The fetched instruction is then decoded, which means that the CPU determines its type and operands, and prepares the necessary circuits to execute it.
The execution of an instruction usually involves several steps, which can be categorized into three phases: fetch, decode, and execute. During the fetch phase, the CPU reads the instruction from memory and loads it into a buffer, called the instruction queue, which can hold one or more pending instructions. During the decode phase, the CPU determines the opcode and the addressing mode of the instruction, and generates signals that activate the appropriate circuits or units. For example, if the instruction is add eax, ebx, the CPU will decode it as an addition of the contents of the register eax with those of ebx, and signal the arithmetic logic unit (ALU) and the register file to fetch the values of eax and ebx, perform the addition, and store the result back in eax.
During the execute phase, the CPU carries out the actual computation, which involves activating the relevant transistors and performing logic operations on the data. The results of the computation are then written back to the appropriate registers or memory locations, and the CPU releases any resources that were used. Depending on the type and complexity of the instruction, the CPU may need to access other resources, such as the cache, the memory controller, the input/output (IO) devices, or the graphics processing unit (GPU), to complete the task.
Modern CPUs can execute multiple instructions concurrently, using a technique called pipelining, which divides the instruction execution into smaller stages and overlaps them. For example, if we have four instructions to execute, A, B, C, and D, and our CPU has a four-stage pipeline, we can assign each instruction to a different stage, and let them progress independently, as shown in the following diagram:
FETCH DECODE EXECUTE WRITE
Cycle 1: A – – –
Cycle 2: A B – –
Cycle 3: A B C –
Cycle 4: A B C D
Cycle 5: – A B D’
Cycle n: – – – –
Each stage of the pipeline can work on a different instruction at the same time, as long as there are no dependencies or hazards between them. A dependency is a condition where the result of one instruction is needed as an input by another instruction that comes later in the pipeline. A hazard is a condition where the pipeline stalls, or waits, for a resource that is not yet available, such as a register or a memory location. Dependencies and hazards can limit the throughput and increase the latency of the pipeline, and require careful handling by the CPU’s control unit and the software that generates the instructions.
Pipelining is just one of many techniques used to improve the performance of CPUs. Other techniques include superscalar execution, which allows the CPU to execute multiple instructions in the same pipeline stage, speculative execution, which predicts the outcome of a branch instruction before it is resolved, out-of-order execution, which reorders the instructions dynamically to maximize the usage of the resources, and register renaming, which allows the CPU to reuse the same register for multiple instructions by renaming it to a different physical register. These techniques are often implemented in modern CPUs as microarchitectural features, which are invisible to the user and the software, but can significantly affect the performance and the security of the system.
II. The Challenges of Multicore Processing
Until now, we have assumed that a CPU has only one processing core, or unit, which can execute one instruction at a time. In reality, however, most modern CPUs have multiple cores, each of which can execute multiple instructions concurrently, using the same or a different pipelining scheme. The advantage of having multiple cores is that it can increase the processing power and the energy efficiency of the CPU, by allowing it to share the workload among the cores and reduce the idle time or the waiting time in the pipeline. The disadvantage is that it can introduce more complexity and challenges, both for the hardware and the software.
A. Parallelism: The Key to Multicore Performance
The reason why multiple cores can improve performance is that they can exploit two forms of parallelism: task-level parallelism and data-level parallelism. Task-level parallelism means that some tasks or programs can be split into independent subtasks, that can run on different cores without interfering with each other. For example, if we want to render a 3D animation, we can divide the scene into multiple frames, and assign each frame to a different core, which can render it in parallel with the other frames. Task-level parallelism can also occur in applications that run multiple threads, which are independent sequences of instructions that can run concurrently in the same process or program.
Data-level parallelism means that some tasks or algorithms can be applied to multiple pieces of data at once, using the same or slightly different instructions. For example, if we want to multiply two matrices, A and B, we can divide each matrix into smaller submatrices, and assign them to different cores, which can apply the multiplication in parallel by using the same formula. Similarly, if we want to sort a large array of numbers, we can divide it into smaller subarrays, and sort them in parallel, using the same or slightly different sorting algorithms.
Parallelism can increase the throughput and the efficiency of multicore CPUs, but it also introduces more challenges and limitations. One challenge is that not all tasks or programs can be parallelized easily, due to dependencies, data sharing, or synchronization requirements. For example, if we want to compute the factorial of a number recursively, we cannot parallelize it easily, because each step depends on the previous step. Another challenge is that parallelism can increase the risk of race conditions, which occur when multiple access or modify the same memory location or resource simultaneously, without proper synchronization or ordering. Race conditions can lead to inconsistent or incorrect results, or even crashes or deadlocks.
To overcome these challenges, parallel programming techniques and frameworks have been developed, which aim to simplify the process of designing, debugging, and optimizing parallel code. Some of these techniques include thread-level parallelism, message passing, fork-join, task parallelism, data flow, and parallel patterns, which provide abstractions and libraries that can handle the synchronization, communication, and load balancing aspects of parallelism. Popular parallel programming frameworks include OpenMP, MPI, CUDA, OpenCL, TBB, and SIMD.
B. Cache Coherence: The Art of Sharing
Another challenge of multicore processing is cache coherence, which refers to the problem of ensuring that each core has an up-to-date and consistent view of the shared memory or caches. When a CPU reads data from memory, it typically stores a copy of it in its cache, which is a fast and small memory that is closer to the CPU than the main memory and the disk. The cache can hold the most frequently accessed data, and can provide faster access times than the main memory, but it can also introduce more latency and overhead due to the mechanics of cache misses and hits.
When multiple cores access the same memory location, they might have different copies of the data in their caches, which can lead to inconsistencies or errors if they do not update or invalidate the copies properly. For example, if core A writes a new value to a memory location, but core B still uses its cached copy, it might get the old value and use it erroneously. Likewise, if core A reads a value from a memory location that core B is about to modify and write, it might get the wrong value and use it erroneously. To avoid these problems, modern CPUs use cache coherence protocols, which are protocols that ensure that each core observes a consistent order of memory operations, and updates its cache accordingly.
There are several types of cache coherence protocols, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. One popular type is the MESI protocol, which stands for Modified, Exclusive, Shared, and Invalid. In this protocol, each cache line is assigned a state that represents its current status:
– Modified: the cache line is owned by one core, and has been modified but not written back to memory
– Exclusive: the cache line is owned by one core, and has not been shared with any other core
– Shared: the cache line is shared by multiple cores, but none of them have modified it
– Invalid: the cache line is not valid, either because it has not been loaded yet, or because it has been invalidated by another core
When a core wants to read or write a memory location, it sends a request to the other cores and the memory controller, and waits for a response. If the cache line is in the Modified state, the owner of the line writes it back to memory and changes it to Exclusive, which allows the requesting core to read it exclusively. If the cache line is in the Shared state, it is copied to the requesting core’s cache, and the state changes to Shared. If the cache line is in the Exclusive state, it is sent to the requesting core, which becomes the new owner, and the state changes to Shared. If the cache line is in the Invalid state, the requesting core loads it from memory and changes it to Exclusive.
Cache coherence protocols are essential for correct and efficient operation of multicore CPUs, but they also introduce more complexity and overhead, especially in large-scale systems that involve multiple sockets or nodes. Some of the challenges of cache coherence include false sharing, which occurs when two threads share the same cache line excessively and cause more invalidations and misses than necessary, and cache thrashing, which occurs when the cache is filled with irrelevant data and cannot store the useful data. To optimize cache coherence, software developers can employ several strategies, such as reducing the data sharing, aligning the data structures to the cache line size, and using cache-aware algorithms.
III. The Future of CPU Performance
So far, we have covered the basics of CPU architecture, instruction execution, and multicore processing, but we have not yet explored the latest trends and innovations in CPU performance. In this section, we will highlight some of the emerging technologies and applications that promise to push the boundaries of what CPUs can do, and how they can shape our digital lives in the coming years.
A. Vectorization: Supercharging Parallelism
Vectorization is a technique that allows CPUs to perform multiple operations on multiple data elements at once, using vector instructions. A vector is a collection of data elements of the same type, such as integers or floating-point numbers, that can be processed together as a single unit. A vector instruction is an instruction that operates on one or more vectors, and can perform complex operations such as addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, square root, transcendent functions, and more, all in parallel. For example, if we want to add two vectors, A and B, we can use a vector instruction like this:
v = A + B
where v is the resulting vector that contains the element-wise sum of A and B. Vectorization can improve the performance and the energy efficiency of many applications that involve heavy computation, such as image processing, scientific calculations, and machine learning.
Vectorization is not a new idea, and has been used in some form since the 1960s, but it has become more prevalent and powerful in recent years, thanks to several factors. One factor is the increasing complexity and diversity of the data that needs to be processed, such as images, videos, and audio, which can benefit from highly parallel and vectorized algorithms. Another factor is the increasing number of cores and threads that are available in modern CPUs, which can feed the vector units with more data and instructions in parallel. A third factor is the increasing support for vectorization in programming languages and frameworks, such as C, C++, Fortran, and OpenACC, which can generate vectorized code automatically or with minimal changes to the original code.
One of the most notable advancements in vectorization is the introduction of SIMD (single instruction multiple data) units, which are specialized units that can perform the same instruction on multiple
Image Credit: Pexels